ad_1]
The controversy surrounding Carnatic vocalist Thodur Madabusi Krishna, or TM Krishna as he’s popularly recognized, intensified with the Supreme Court docket on Monday passing an order that he shouldn’t be recognised because the recipient of the MS Subbulakshmi award as an ‘interim measure’. Right here’s all the things it’s good to know in regards to the controversy. (Additionally Learn: TM Krishna’s Sangita Kalanidhi controversy defined: Why some Carnatic musicians are opposing his honour)
What did the Supreme Court docket say?
A bench of Justices, Hrishikesh Roy and SVN Bhatti, handed the order on a plea filed by Subbulakshmi’s grandson V Srinivasan, who alleged Krishna had made ‘scandalous remarks’ in opposition to the late singer, other than ‘misogynistic’ feedback about his grandmother on social media and in articles. Because of this, the SC declared that the vocalist shouldn’t be recognised as an award recipient for now.
As per PTI, the bench stated, “The court docket is conscious of the respect and honour that MS Subbulakshmi instructions all throughout music lovers spreading throughout all spectrums. She is likely one of the most distinguished singers, and though she handed away in December 2004, her melodious voice continues to convey nice pleasure to her followers,” including, “As an interim measure, because the award has already been awarded, we deem it apt to say that 4th defendant TM Krishna shouldn’t be recognised as a recipient of the MS Subbulakshmi award.”
The award, sponsored by The Hindu Group, was introduced to Krishna by the Music Academy in Chennai on Sunday night. Shrinivasan had approached the Excessive Court docket, difficult the Academy’s resolution to award Krishna on Friday, December 13. It was conferred after a division bench of the HC put aside the interim injunction granted by a single decide, that restrained the Music Academy and The Hindu from freely giving the award to him.
In 2017, Krishna spoke about Subbulakshmi in Hyderabad, stating that she had distanced herself from her ‘Devadasi origins’ to ‘determine as and turn into a super Brahmin lady’. He requested, “If MS’s voice got here from a darkish, non-upper-caste beauty-ish girl, would all of us have fun her like we do right now? Her music was what it was due to the sorrow in her.”
The SC clarified that its order shouldn’t be seen as a mirrored image on the Madras Music Academy, The Hindu Group, or Krishna’s musical skills whilst they referred to as it a ‘very, essential and delicate challenge’.
Why is TM Krishna controversial?
Krishna was awarded the Sangita Kalanidhi 2024 by the Music Academy, Chennai, on March 18. N Murali, President of the Madras Music Academy, acknowledged that Krishna had a ‘highly effective voice’, had ‘adherence to custom in relation to the artwork’, was ‘specializing in its exploratory versus tightly outlined constructions’ and used music as a ‘instrument for social reform’. Carnatic vocalist Vidushi sisters Rajani and Gayatri, Harikatha exponents Dushyanth Sridhar and Visakha Hari, and others opposed him receiving the award.
Krishna’s activism in opposition to caste discrimination and caste favouritism within the Carnatic music system has usually drawn ire. He had boycotted the favored Chennai Music Season, normally held in December, for being ‘non-inclusive’ and ‘shunning non-Brahmin musicians’ and sure artwork varieties. He even began his music competition in February 2016 referred to as the Uroor-Olcott Kuppam Marghazi Vizha. Via one other competition referred to as Svanubhava, he needed the viewers to entry artwork varieties that mainstream Carnatic musicians didn’t recognise. Krishna can also be a staunch follower of EV Ramaswamy ‘Periyar’ and Dravidian values.
With inputs from PTI
