Apple mentioned on Tuesday it plans to ask a US choose to dismiss a lawsuit filed by the Justice Division and 15 states in March that alleged the iPhone maker monopolized the smartphone market, damage smaller rivals and drove up costs.
In a letter to US District Choose Julien X. Neals in New Jersey, Apple mentioned “removed from being a monopolist, Apple faces fierce competitors from well-established rivals, and the criticism fails to allege that Apple has the power to cost supra-competitive costs or prohibit output within the alleged smartphone markets.”
Within the letter to the choose, Apple mentioned the DOJ depends on a brand new “idea of antitrust legal responsibility that no courtroom has acknowledged.”
The federal government is predicted to reply inside seven days to the Apple letter, which the courtroom requires events to submit, hoping to expedite circumstances earlier than advancing to a probably extra strong and costly effort to dismiss a lawsuit.
The Justice Division alleges that Apple makes use of its market energy to get more cash from shoppers, builders, content material creators, artists, publishers, small companies and retailers. The civil lawsuit accuses Apple of an unlawful monopoly on smartphones maintained by imposing contractual restrictions on, and withholding vital entry from, builders.
The Justice Division, which didn’t instantly remark, has beforehand mentioned Apple prices as a lot as $1,599 for an iPhone and makes a bigger revenue than any rival. Officers additionally mentioned Apple imposes hidden prices on varied enterprise companions – from software program builders to bank card corporations and even rivals similar to Alphabet’s Google, in ways in which finally increase costs for shoppers.
Apple rejected the federal government’s contentions that the iPhone has saved shoppers “locked in” to the units. “Somebody sad with Apple’s limitations has each incentive to change to competitor platforms that ostensibly shouldn’t have these limitations,” the letter mentioned.
“Shoppers mustn’t need to pay greater costs as a result of corporations violate the antitrust legal guidelines,” Legal professional Normal Merrick Garland mentioned in March. “If left unchallenged, Apple will solely proceed to strengthen its smartphone monopoly.”
© Thomson Reuters 2024
